A Local’s Guide to the Best Restaurants in Reykjavík

Iceland’s culinary scene is vast and slightly unusual, from sheep head to fermented shark. The cold weather and surrounding oceans call for warm, hearty soups and a range of meat and fish dishes. As we all know, there is no better way to learn about foreign culture than through its cuisine - for a taste of traditional Icelandic food, read our local’s guide to restaurants in Iceland.

How Expensive is Fine Dining in Iceland?

If you are planning a trip to Iceland, you should be aware that Iceland is generally considered to be quite expensive. Food is no exception, particularly if you are keen on trying somewhere a little fancier. Fine dining establishments are considerably more expensive, though some argue similar to those in capitals like New York City and London. You could be looking at a price tag of over $100 for 2 courses, so it’s worth considering your choices carefully.

If you’re on a budget, don’t worry - there are some more affordable restaurants around that you can opt for.

Are There Many Cuisine Options in Reykjavík?

Reykjavík is a great place to try Icelandic specialities, but of course, there are other options too. You’ll find a lot of American and Asian establishments around the center of the city. It’s worth noting that many of the Michelin-star restaurants in the city do specialise in a modern twist on traditional Icelandic cuisine. 

Best Fine Dining in Reykjavík

Here are a few of the best restaurants in the city that we recommend you add to your list.

 

Sægreifinn (The Sea Baron), Reykjavík

Location: Geirsgata 4a, 101 Reykjavík

Open: Everyday 11:30-17:00, 18:00-22:00

Saegreifinn, otherwise known as The Sea Baron, specializes in classic Icelandic seafood dishes. Being centred between the Green Sea and the North Atlantic Ocean, the small island of Iceland is reliant on its fishing industry. Taking advantage of its marine surroundings, The Sea Baron serves a wide selection of seafood to cater to customers hungry for traditional fish dishes. The restaurant is world-famous for its lobster soup, which has been named the world’s greatest, not only by locals but also by international customers. What’s stopping you from grabbing a bowl?

Islenski Barinn, Reykjavík

Location: Ingólfsstræti 1a, 101 Reykjavík

Open: Sunday - Thursday 11:30-01:00, Friday - Saturday 11:30-03:00

Islenski Barinn presents traditional Icelandic foods with a slightly more contemporary touch. Located in Reykjavík, the restaurant has a warm, bubbly atmosphere, despite the harsh cold outside. Many visitors try the slow-roasted leg of lamb, reindeer meatballs, and warming meat soups. It also must be noted that Islenski Barinn is the only place in the world that serves all Icelandic beers and spirits!

Otto Matur & Drykkur, Hofn

Location: Hafnarbraut, 780 Höfn í Hornafirði

Open: Everyday 17:00-21:00

Otto Matur & Drykkur specializes in classic Icelandic foods with a fresh, modern twist. Otto Matur & Drykkur can be found in the small fishing village of Hofn, which is home to just over two thousand people. This restaurant offers a wide range of delicious cuisine, featuring both land and sea options. Many customers recommend trying smoked fish and meats. The owners ensure that every dish on the menu is freshly homemade with first-class produce from Iceland.

 

Kopar Restaurant, Reykjavík

Location: Geirsgata 3, 101 Reykjavík

Open: Tuesday - Saturday 12:00-15:00, 17:00-21:00, Sunday - Monday 17:00-21:00

Located by the old harbor in Reykjavík, Kopar restaurant presents a menu full of seafood options, which is no surprise considering its waterside location. Meat, vegetarian, and vegan options are found here as well, so do not fear if you aren’t a fish lover. The fine-dining restaurant features a wide range of slightly unusual dishes for the adventurous eater, including cod tongues and fried turkey legs.

Old Iceland, Reykjavík

Location: Laugavegur 72, 101 Reykjavík

Open: Every day 11:30-15:30, 17:00-22:00

Old Iceland is a family-owned restaurant in Reykjavík, providing its customers with a warm, friendly atmosphere and good food. With a focus on serving Icelandic meat and fish, Old Iceland uses herbs and spices grown close by to create traditional and local food. If you are looking for classic Icelandic dishes with a contemporary twist, then this is the perfect place for you!

If you’re keen to make the most of your time in Iceland, venturing outside of the capital is a great way to see it all. Renting a car is the best way to ensure the most freedom and the ability to tick off all of the items on your Iceland bucket list! Browse our rental cars today.

Back